Closing the Elgin Chapter, Portcullis House Event with Stephen Fry.

Closing the Elgin Chapter, Portcullis House Event with Stephen Fry.

Published On: 19 July 2025
Share This Post

As a British citizen, I am baffled. In a time of such turmoil in the world, why not show an immense gesture of friendship to one of our oldest and most beloved friends, Greece.

As an Honorary Greek citizen too, I speak for the Greeks themselves. Please give us back what is rightfully ours – the Parthenon sculptures in the British Museum should be reunited with the rest in the Acropolis Museum– under the luminous Aegean light where they truly belong.

– Victoria Hislop, author and member of BCRPM,the British Committee for the Reunification of the Parthenon Marbles

On Wednesday 16 July, an event was organised by Andrew George, the Liberal Democrat MP for St Ives. The event was entitled ‘Closing the Elgin Chapter.’

At the event, Victoria Hislop spoke, followed by Sir Stephen Fry, then Thangam Debbonaire and Ed Vaizey both members of the House of Lords, plus Roger Michel, Executive Director of the Institute for Digital Archaeology and Tom Harrison, Keeper of the Department of Greece and Rome at the British Museum.

Below Victoria’s words:

Good evening.  I am Victoria Hislop, member of the British Committee for the Reunification of the Parthenon Marbles (BCRPM).   

My belief is that TIME IS OF THE ESSENCE

We know that negotiations are under way for some kind of deal or “arrangement” to return the Parthenon sculptures from the British Museum to Athens. 

It feels like the perfect moment for reunification with the stars aligned and many obstacles out of the way.  Here are just some of the reasons we believe this must be the moment:

 

1.We now have a Labour government (traditionally more sympathetic to reunification) and Keir Starmer is more open to this cause than many of his predecessors.

2.UNESCO voted in its “Committee for promoting the return of cultural property” that Greece’s claim is “legitimate and rightful”. This happened in 2021.

3.It has recently been conclusively confirmed by Turkish officials that the firman Elgin claimed to have had from the Sultan giving him permission to rip the sculptures from the Parthenon does not exist anywhere in their archive. 

Elgin’s actions were not legal, he did not steal the sculptures to SAVE them from destruction or to educate the British population in classical art  – it was vandalism, not an act of philanthropy and he took them with the intention of decorating his own home in Scotland. 

He only sold them to the BM because he had gone bankrupt.  These are much repeated points – but they are FACTS – and shame on anyone including the Museum for not openly acknowledging them.

The claim that Elgin had a firman is entirely fictional.  A firman was a very specific document issued by the Ottoman Sultan.  Quite simply, this has been proved NEVER to have existed – both by the Turkish authorities and through academic research.  It is confirmed in the recent scholarly book by Nikos Stampoulidis, Director of the Acropolis Museum. 

Quite simply, Elgin was a liar.  And it’s the truth to say so.

4. A massive scandal took place less than two years ago at the British Museum and the shadow still hangs over this institution – a systematic theft of thousands of objects from the museum by a senior curator destroyed the museum’s claim to be the best curator for Greek treasures.  Let’s not allow the Museum to forget this.  Nor that they have 1% of their collection on public display.

5.The one-billion-pound plan to refurbish part of the museum, includes a so-called “reimagining” of the entire Western Wing where the sculptures are currently housed, so an optimist might conclude this could be the perfect moment to move them elsewhere (Athens of course).

6.There is a world-wide trend towards repatriation of disputed objects.  Why does the British Museum take such a stubborn stand on this?  It’s a mystery.  Even  more significantly – this is not just REPATRIATION – THIS IS REUNIFICATION – The Parthenon sculptures in the British Museum are PART of one of the most precious and unique works of art in the WORLD.  Why keep them separate?

If the late Pope returned a fragment from the Vatican to Athens*, can we really maintain it’s the wrong thing to do. 

7.Public opinion in the UK has never been more pro-return, so if you combine the whole of the Greek population, the majority of the British public (now up to 60% in a recent poll) who believe the sculpture should be returned, this adds up to many millions of us. 

 

***

So, it’s three years since the talks we know are happening commenced. I am impatient.  Stars do NOT stay aligned for long.

Even during that time massive political changes have happened around the world, not least the rise in populism, return of Trump and tragic and continuing international conflicts.  A lot can happen in a short time especially if it’s bad alas. 

And Nigel Farage is rising terrifyingly in the polls – and if he became our next PM – which is perfectly possible – we can forget reunification/repatriation – whatever we name it – for a very long time.

For all the words that are written, the speeches we all make, the debates we take part in, even demonstrations in front of the Marbles themselves, the will, the desire, has to come from the British Museum.  I sometimes question whether they use a 1963 law that prevents museums from “deaccessioning” – I think that’s just a grand word for returning –  as merely a means of procrastination. 

We all know that laws can be undone or reviewed.  It happens all the time.  They are pieces of paper.

***

As a British citizen, I am baffled.  In a time of such turmoil in the world, why not show an immense gesture of friendship to one of our oldest and most beloved friends, Greece. 

As an Honorary Greek citizen too, I speak for the Greeks themselves.  Please give us back what is rightfully ours – the Parthenon sculptures in the British Museum should be reunited with the rest in the Acropolis Museum– under the luminous Aegean light where they truly belong.

 

* The British Museum web site still says: Most of the sculptures are roughly equally divided between Athens and London, but important pieces are also held by other major European museum including the Louvre and Vatican Museums.

 

Share This Post