Food for thought

Food for thought

Published On: 5 August 2025
Share This Post

I thought of the shed on Park Lane, the possible arrangements in Elgin, and the Parthenon Museum’s uppermost gallery, ready and waiting. I thought how it’d be such a better compromise than their current display – in sight of their temple, in that Attic light, and of course reunited with their surviving counterparts. None of which undermines a copy, made with 150 years’ more experience in conservatorship, going into the BM. Food for thought.

– Stuart O'Hara, BCRPM member

In the course of the Marbles debate, we’ve spent a lot of time refuting the claim that the sculptures’ being in London gives more people the opportunity to see them. We’ve got the ripostes in our back pocket: only a third of BM visitors go to Room 18; Athens is hardly a tourist backwater; if they were to have the greatest exposure, they’d be in Shanghai &c &c. But I’ve just been to the Cast Courts at the V&A and had a moment of clarity about the exposure argument. There’s a subtext when it counters our insistence that the Marbles shouldn’t be in the BM. It’s a good thing that so many people can see them in London despite the iffy nature of their acquisition.

The Cast Courts contain, well, plaster casts of statuary and architectural wonders, altarpieces &c. They were built in 1873 so, granted, a few generations removed from the 7th Earl of Elgin’s personal style of shopping, but it’s clear enough that cutting-edge copies were considered Good Enough for edification and artistic study even at the height of imperial pomp. The Courts were designed to hold their biggest cast, Trajan’s Column, which is displayed in two halves, the lower including its pedestal. Let’s weigh up the advantages and disadvantages of this display over the real thing in Rome.

PRO

  • You can see more of the column up close than in Rome.
  • You can get closer to it than in Rome.
  • Because of the first-floor walkway, you can see some of the column on a level at height from around 3m away.
  • It doesn’t terminate in Pope Sixtus V’s incongruous statue of St Peter.

CON

  • The top of each half is still too far away for close scrutiny.
  • The very top is as far away from the viewer as the halfway point is in Rome.
  • You lose the sense of the whole – it’s a film shown on TV, with ad breaks.
  • The halfway point is at ground level, closer than the base atop its pedestal, making it likely that the viewer begins the narrative – the conquest of Dacia in the early 100s CE – in media res, in a way not intended by its creators.
  • The base of the column is best viewed looking down from the first-floor walkway, somewhere you usually reach after entering the Cast Courts at ground level.
  • The very highest walkway is out of bounds and is a long way from the column.

It’s amusing to think of ways of increasing visibility of Trajan’s Column. The full height would pierce the skylight, but the pedestal could sit in a pit, or the upper half be raised a couple of metres. There could be a staircase winding around it, maybe a slide to get back down to earth. Perhaps the ideal solution is to suspend each half parallel to the ground like the blue whale in the Natural History Museum. They could slowly rotate while an airport-style travelator inches you along, experiencing Trajan’s campaign like a spool of film. For now, the ‘ideal’ route is to start on the first floor, crane your neck to the halfway point, go downstairs to start the upper half, then schlep upstairs again. Not terribly accessible.

Remind you of anything? It’s as skewiffy an arrangement as the Marbles’ in Room 18 of the BM. As far as I’m concerned, the fact that it’s a copy of Trajan’s Column doesn’t come into it, and it doesn’t feel like a compromise, even though it is. It’s still a magnificent thing, and amazing that it’s here at all, a copy I felt privileged to study. I thought of the shed on Park Lane, the possible arrangements in Elgin, and the Parthenon Museum’s uppermost gallery, ready and waiting. I thought how it’d be such a better compromise than their current display – in sight of their temple, in that Attic light, and of course reunited with their surviving counterparts. None of which undermines a copy, made with 150 years’ more experience in conservatorship, going into the BM. Food for thought.

 

Stuart O’Hara is a BCRPM member

Share This Post