Independent adds a reader poll to their latest Parthenon Marbles debate

Independent adds a reader poll to their latest Parthenon Marbles debate

Published On: 15 July 2025
Share This Post
paul cartledge 2

Bayeux Tapestry loan reignites Elgin Marbles debate. As Macron lends the Bayeux Tapestry to Britain, should we go further – and return treasures like the Elgin Marbles permanently, not just on temporary loan? Asks the Independent.

The article looks at how President Macron’s decision to loan the Bayeux Tapestry has ignited the debate on the reunification of the Parthenon Marbles.

Professor Paul Cartledge, Vice-Chair of this committee, the BCRPM gave this quote to Greek newspaper Kathimerini: 

The Bayeux Tapestry is not even a very inexact parallel, unfortunately, it is not a parallel in any sense whatsoever. Probably made in south-eastern England, and somehow transported across the Channel to Bayeux, it does not have an obvious and unquestionably secure original home (as do the Parthenon Marbles – the clue is in the ‘Parthenon’) nor does it have a wider historical context from which it was untimely and violently wrenched (as were the Marbles from a building, still significantly standing,  on the Acropolis). Nor is it a case of ‘reunification’, since the Bayeux Tapestry is a single whole artefact and more or less intact, whereas the Marbles are dis-united and invite, or rather demand, reunification – on cultural, political, aesthetic and yes also diplomatic grounds.

And indeed the surviving Parthenon Marbles are currently almost equally divided between two museums, the Acropolis Museum in Athens and the British Museum in London. In some cases the actual piece of sculpture is literally half in Athens, half in London. As is the case below: the six pack of Poseidon is in Athens, while the torso with the back, shoulders and collarbones are housed at the British Museum in London after they were removed by Thomas Bruce, lord of Elgin. So the plaster cast of this torso forms part of the pediment one sees in Athens. 

 

“So what’s the answer? Are cultural loans a useful compromise, or just a stalling tactic? Should Britain begin returning historic artefacts to their countries of origin – and if so, where should the line be drawn?” Asks the Independent.

The Independent also wants to hear from you, if you want you can share your thoughts in the comments and vote in the poll. They will feature the most compelling responses and discuss the results in the coming days.

All you have to do is sign up and register your details – then you can take part in the debate. You can also sign up by clicking ‘log in’ on the top right-hand corner of the Independent’s  screen, follow the link here.

Today Wednesday 16 July the poll looks like this:

*60% Yes, they should be returned, they were never ours to keep’

 

* 30% ‘No, they belong in the British Museum‘

 

* 10% ‘only as part of a reciprocal loan’

 

 

Share This Post