Stone of Destiny, John Major, the Parthenon Marbles and restitution in the 90’s

Stone of Destiny, John Major, the Parthenon Marbles and restitution in the 90’s

Published On: 3 July 2025
Share This Post

The return of the Stone of Scone gives the Greeks a peg onto which to hang another formal request and possibly achieve more international support than has been the case in the past.

‘The return of the Stone of Destiny to Scotland would herald a spate of restitution claims, civil servants warned in the 1990s, as they criticised John Major, then the prime minister, for “setting a precedent”.

A government file released at the National Archives revealed that in 1996 a senior civil servant at the Department of National Heritage wrote that if they had been consulted by Major they would have advised against returning the stone.

Lynn Gates, the head of the cultural property unit, wrote to the then-secretary of state, Virginia Bottomley, saying the return of the stone would lead to a flood of claims from countries including Greece, Egypt and Nigeria for the return of objects held by British institutions.’ Writes David Sanderson, Arts Correspondent of The Times.

The Stone of Destiny, also known as the Stone of Scone and the Coronation Stone, had been used as a crowning seat for Scottish monarchs at Scone Palace up until the late 13th century when Edward I of England took it to Westminster, where it was then used by English monarchs.

In 1996, in a decision supported by Tony Blair, then the leader of the opposition, Major said it was “appropriate to return it to its historic homeland” on the 700th anniversary of its removal.

He said in a statement to the House of Commons on July 3 that the slab of sandstone held a “special place in the hearts of Scots”.

Gates wrote that in 1985 Britain had refused a formal request from Greece for the return of the Elgin Marbles.

The civil servant added: “The return of the Stone of Scone gives the Greeks a peg onto which to hang another formal request and possibly achieve more international support than has been the case in the past.”

To read the full article in The Times, follow the link here.

The Stone of Destiny returned briefly to Westminster Abbey to play a role in the coronation in 2023.

Share This Post