Museums and the Spoils of Empire: From the Benin Bronzes to Those Marbles Again

Museums and the Spoils of Empire: From the Benin Bronzes to Those Marbles Again

Published On: 23 June 2025
Share This Post

Museums and the Spoils of Empire: From the Benin Bronzes to Those Marbles Again

Catharine Titi

French National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS)

This is an original manuscript of an article published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History on 19 June 2025, available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/03086534.2025.2517135.

 

A brief history of contested objects

In 1815, in the wake of the French defeat at Waterloo, British foreign secretary Viscount Castlereagh and the Duke of Wellington campaigned for the repatriation of Napoleon’s European loot.[i] Castlereagh proclaimed the French loot to be ‘contrary to every principle of justice, and to the usages of modern warfare’.[ii] The logic of repatriation carried the day, and masterpieces such as the Laocoön Group made their way back to Italy, where they can be admired today.[iii] But although Castlereagh was keen to see the return of European treasures to their countries of origin, he appeared to forget that the French troops had also plundered Egypt. Was Egypt less worthy than Europe to reclaim its stolen treasures? Castlereagh’s selective memory may have a different explanation. A few years earlier, Napoleon had been made to hand over most of his Egyptian loot to the British army.[iv] Egyptian antiquities, such as the Rosetta Stone, had already made their way to the British Museum. Castlereagh may have been eager to apply principles of justice to the treasures that enriched the Louvre, but he drew the line at the British Museum.

Over the years, more contested treasures made their way to the Bloomsbury institution. In 1816, the House of Commons purchased for the museum the antiquities brought to the country by Thomas Bruce, 7th Earl of Elgin, including the famous Parthenon marbles. Misinformation is rife in this case, and many would have us believe that in dismantling the Parthenon Elgin acted lawfully and was motivated by his desire to save the ancient temple and advance the arts in Great Britain. But the recorded facts reveal a different story. Contemporary accounts, including Elgin’s own correspondence and the testimony offered by British ambassador Sir Robert Adair, show unambiguously that Elgin never had any authorisation to act as he did.[v] The removal of the Parthenon marbles was achieved by means of bribes to the local Ottoman officials, who feared for their lives in case the central Ottoman government was apprised of what was happening to the Parthenon. Elgin himself admitted the bribes and expected the British government to reimburse him for them. He listed the bribes in a letter appended to an 1816 House of Commons report, a document publicly available online.[vi] Elgin did not save the Parthenon but caused instead the greatest destruction the monument suffered since a Venetian bombing in 1687. His motives were not altruistic either. In his correspondence, he detailed his interest in these historical pieces as decoration for his Scottish mansion. When he ran into financial difficulties, he changed tack and attempted to create a private museum that would admit paying customers. As this plan proved uneconomical, he decided to sell the marbles to the government but did not donate them. Deep in debt, he haggled over the price and rejected the government’s initial offer. At the time of the purchase, he was still trying to put pressure on the government, threatening to sell ‘his’ collection abroad if the government were not interested.

Military expeditions in the latter half of the 19th century brought more treasures to the British Museum. The Abyssinian Campaign of 1868, an expedition to Abyssinia (modern-day Ethiopia), led to the destruction of the Maqdala fortress and hundreds of deaths. This military assault also resulted in numerous artefacts ending up in the British Museum. These include silver chalices, crosses, silk textiles, jewellery, weapons, and sacred altar tablets known as tabots.[vii]

In 1897, a British punitive expedition to Benin City (now in Nigeria) led to the establishment of British colonial rule over the historic Kingdom of Benin and the looting of hundreds of artefacts, collectively known as the ‘Benin Bronzes’ – a somewhat misleading term, given that not all of them are made of bronze. Other materials used include ivory, wood and leather. These objects became dispersed around the world. The Ethnological Museum in Berlin, for example, held a large collection of Benin bronzes until it signed a contract in 2022 transferring ownership to Nigeria.[viii] Subsequently, a third of the collection was left on loan in Berlin.[ix] The British Museum has the largest collection of Benin bronzes, with over 900 pieces.[x] However, unlike other museums, it refuses to consider their repatriation, as we will see. This is despite the fact that most of them are in its storerooms: only 100 are on public display at any one time.[xi]

 

British Museum exceptionalism: The director’s view

Today, the British Museum acknowledges that its collection is contested.[xii] In an interview published in The Times Magazine in May 2025, the new director of the British Museum, Nicholas Cullinan, discussed this and other issues relating to the museum.[xiii] His views, as expressed in the interview, are worth considering since they are likely to shape the museum’s policies in the immediate future.

Cullinan explained that his vision is ‘not to reinvent the museum for the 21st century but to restore its glories’ and that modernising it is all ‘about honouring tradition’. There seems to be something contradictory about wanting to modernise an institution while aiming to change nothing, instead looking to its past glories. But one thing is certain: the door to repatriation is firmly closed.

When asked about the Benin bronzes, Cullinan made it clear that repatriation was not on the table. Instead, he chose to focus on seemingly irrelevant points: ‘There are a great many Benin bronzes. It’s all fluid. We have a fantastic relationship with MOWAA [Museum of West African Art] … They might want to borrow other things’. When asked about the Parthenon marbles, which he described as ‘talismanic objects of this museum’, he responded: ‘We’d love an innovative partnership with Greece where we would lend things and they would lend things back, and we can share knowledge and opportunity rather than debate ownership.’ Then he said a bit more about lending: ‘I feel more comfortable with loaning items. This collection has been formed over three centuries. It is the world’s greatest collection. I don’t see my job as undoing that.’

There’s a lot to unpack there. But let me start by pointing out that a loan is not a repatriation.[xiv] A request for repatriation should not be confused with a request for a loan or a partnership. These are entirely different things. While the rhetoric is beautiful, offering a loan or a partnership in response to a repatriation request is not only inadequate but also distracts from the real issues in dispute. Cullinan all but admitted this when he said that talking about collaborations ‘turns this narrative of everything being stolen or you are hoarding things into a more interesting … story.’

 As for the museum’s ‘talismanic objects’, the riposte came quickly. In an open letter, prominent British historian and academic Paul Cartledge, novelist Victoria Hislop, and actress Dame Janet Suzman wrote on behalf of the British Committee for the Reunification of the Parthenon Marbles (BCRPM): ‘A talisman is something that brings good luck.  How can stolen goods bring good fortune to any institution?’[xv]

In the interview, Cullinan also shared his view that there are two types of museums: ‘mirrors that reflect your identity, and windows onto the world’. ‘The more you have these divisive discussions around nationalism, the more [the British Museum has] a role to play in giving people another way of thinking about the interconnected world’. The nationalism-internationalism theory to which Cullinan alludes here is old. Its most famous proponent was academic John Henry Merryman, who argued powerfully against cultural heritage export controls in the 1980s and whose positions have become largely outdated.

In short, the theory of ‘cultural nationalism’ and ‘cultural internationalism’ held that countries that control the export of their cultural heritage do so for nationalistic purposes, while countries that oppose other countries’ export controls are ‘internationalist’. It was this same theory that led British Museum director David Wilson to make some surprising claims in 1986. Wilson said that ‘[t]o rip the Elgin Marbles from the walls of the British Museum is a much greater disaster than the threat of blowing up the Parthenon’.[xvi] Wilson may have been unaware that he was using the same argument as the French in 1815, who resisted the repatriation of Napoleon’s European loot by claiming that ‘the break-up of the unique collection assembled in the Louvre would be an act of vandalism’.[xvii] This did not stop Castlereagh from seeking ‘justice’. Wilson then made an even more startling statement, comparing those who demand the repatriation of the Parthenon marbles to Hitler and Mussolini.[xviii]

Cullinan’s discourse is more measured, but does his argument stand up to scrutiny? Are those who display their own artefacts and history motivated by nationalism, and does the British Museum rightly claim the moral high ground as ‘a window onto the world’? Is a museum like Tate Britain with its unique collection of British Pre-Raphaelite paintings ‘nationalist’? Or is the United Kingdom driven by nationalism in implementing export controls on cultural objects? In the United Kingdom, when a cultural object is intended for export, an independent body, the Reviewing Committee on the Export of Works of Art and Objects of Cultural Interest, advises the Secretary of State for the Department for Culture, Media and Sport on whether to grant an export licence. To make its decision, the Reviewing Committee uses the three Waverley criteria. The first of these criteria is whether the object in question is ‘closely connected with our history and national life’.[xix] If an object meets any of the Waverley criteria, the Reviewing Committee will recommend deferring the decision on the export licence. Does this focus on national history and life make the United Kingdom ‘nationalist’? Ultimately, is a museum called the British Museum, which wants to prevent its contested collection from leaving its walls – and, mostly, its storerooms –[xx] the opposite of ‘nationalist’, ‘a window onto the world’? That is a curious perception indeed.

The museum has long relied on the much-vaunted value of ‘world’ or ‘universal’ museums. For example, regarding the Parthenon marbles, the museum claims that ‘there’s a positive advantage and public benefit in having the sculptures divided between two … museums … [T]here’s a great public benefit to seeing the sculptures within the context of the world collection of the British Museum, in order to deepen our understanding of their significance within world cultural history’.[xxi]  Let us take the two arguments in turn.

To claim that there is advantage in having the Parthenon marbles divided between two museums is certainly puzzling. In the 18th century, Quatremère de Quincy had deplored the spoliation of Italian art with the pithy phrase: ‘Diviser c’est détruire.’ To divide is to destroy.[xxii] You cannot turn this simple truth on its head. The narratives of dismembered cultural heritage are inevitably fractured themselves. Take the example of Slabs 26 and 27 from the north frieze of the Parthenon, which depict a scene from the apobates race, an equestrian competition in which athletes dismounted and then remounted a moving chariot. The two slabs are torn horizontally: the horses’ bodies in Slab 26 are in the British Museum, but their tails in the top right corner of the same slab are in Athens; the athlete’s head and upper body in Slab 27 is in the British Museum, but the lower half of his body is in Athens. His shield is torn in two: each museum has half. The body of the driver of the next set of horses is likewise torn as is the front part of the horses themselves: heads in London, torso and legs in Athens. What exactly is the advantage or public benefit in seeing heads severed from their bodies? Are the heads viewed in London deepening ‘our understanding of their significance within world cultural history’?

Then, there’s the question of the educational value of world museums. Does magic happen when we view fragments of the Parthenon, fragments of the temple of Bassae, Chinese ceramics, Easter Island moai, Benin bronzes, the roaring lion from King Nebuchadnezzar II’s throne room in Babylon, and Egyptian mummies, all in the space of the same afternoon? Do we leave the museum conscious of the fact that some of these items are so disparate that they are separated by over four millennia? Are we encouraged to draw comparisons between Athenian democracy and the political systems of Babylon or Egypt? Do we even understand what we are looking at when we gaze upon the Parthenon marbles in the Duveen Gallery? Do we remember that these were parts of a building before it was dismantled? On the Parthenon itself, the marbles were facing out. In the British Museum, they are displayed looking inwards. In addition, the metopes that once ran all around the Parthenon are placed in alcoves to the left and right of the pediments; parts of the frieze that were on the short sides of the Parthenon have been placed on the long side of the Duveen Gallery. Do we leave the museum understanding what a moai is? The answer for most of us is, sadly, ‘no’.

Cullinan himself said it in the interview: ‘Most people come to the Rosetta Stone first. Then they go to the Parthenon sculptures and can get dispirited not knowing where to go next.’ The experience does not deepen our understanding of the connections between the objects on display, nor does it help us to understand their role in world history. It is a ‘dispiriting’ experience.

Finally, as we have seen, Cullinan believes that he is curating ‘the world’s greatest collection”. He says: ‘This is a global museum for everyone and we’re not going to be embarrassed about that any more [sic]’. But the British Museum is not a ‘museum for everyone’. It is a museum for those with the capacity to visit London. This was aptly captured in an article about the Benin bronzes published in The New York Times by a Nigerian artist. He emphasised that many of his compatriots have never set eyes ‘on such an important part of their history’ and discussed those heirlooms ‘whose significance was lost on the vast majority of the museum visitors sauntering by’.[xxiii] As for the ‘greatness’ of the museum’s collection, that is a point on which we disagree. The Uffizi in Florence has a great collection. The Acropolis Museum in Athens has a great collection. The Heraklion Archaeological Museum has a great collection. The British Museum has a ‘contested’ collection. The two seem to me to be incompatible.

 

There is another way

Not everyone is attached to tradition and the glories of imperialism. Many British institutions, from universities to museums, have done their part. They have repatriated contested cultural heritage,[xxiv] and the sky did not fall. The British Museum may refuse to restore the Parthenon marbles to Athens, but others have already returned fragments of the Parthenon: the University of Heidelberg, Italy together with the Antonino Salinas Museum in Palermo, and the Vatican Museums. Benin bronzes are also currently being repatriated to Nigeria by numerous countries and institutions worldwide. The Netherlands is one such country, and its approach is an interesting example that warrants further consideration.

In 2020, a Dutch advisory report recommended the unconditional repatriation of cultural heritage looted from former Dutch colonies and now in the possession of the Dutch state.[xxv] The report was subsequently adopted by the government, which also agreed that other objects of special significance to their country of origin, as well as objects taken from the colonies of other countries, are eligible for repatriation.[xxvi] Since then, acting on the advice of the newly formed Colonial Collections Committee, the Dutch government has repatriated hundreds of artefacts to Indonesia, Sri Lanka, Ysleta del Sur Pueblo, and Nigeria.[xxvii] Examination of other requests is ongoing.

A key aspect of the new Dutch policy is that the repatriations are driven by the need to do justice. According to the 2020 advisory report, acknowledging and rectifying injustice must be ‘a core principle of the policy’, and this not only when the object was lost as a result of Dutch colonialism: ‘[I]f the request concerns a cultural object that was lost involuntarily, … here too the guiding principle must be the redress of an injustice. This is because, regardless of whether the Netherlands itself played a part in causing the original injustice, as the current owner of the cultural object it is the only party capable of rectifying that injustice.’[xxviii] Others may prefer to barricade themselves behind their past glories. But Dutch museums are reinventing themselves for the 21st century and show us a way forward.

The Dutch are right: justice does have a role to play in repatriations, and this is nothing new. During a debate in the House of Commons in June 1816, many British MPs voiced their concerns about purchasing the Parthenon marbles. One of them commented that ‘he was not so enamoured of those headless ladies as to forget another lady, which was justice’.[xxix] In a speech made in 1871 with reference to the Maqdala treasure, the then British prime minister William Ewart Gladstone said that he ‘deeply regretted that those articles were ever brought from Abyssinia, and could not conceive why they were so brought. … [H]e deeply lamented, for the sake of the country, and for the sake of all concerned, that those articles, to us insignificant, though probably to the Abyssinians sacred and imposing symbols, or at least hallowed by association, were thought fit to be brought away by a British Army. … If those articles were acquired it should be … with the view of their being held only until they could be restored’.[xxx]

The repatriation debate is not about practicality or convenience. It is about justice – the same principle that made Castlereagh demand the return of Napoleon’s loot back in 1815. Recognising that a cultural object is contested is only the first step. Rather than trying to restore past glories, the next step must be to do the honourable thing. Do justice: repatriate.

 

[i] Note delivered by Viscount Castlereagh to the Allied Ministers (11 September 1815) and Dispatch from the Duke of Wellington to Viscount Castlereagh (23 September 1815), reprinted in Georg Friedrich von Martens, Nouveau recueil de traités d’alliance, de paix, de trêve, de neutralité, de commerce, de limites, d’échange etc. et de plusieurs autres actes: 1814-1815 (vol 2, Librairie de Dieterich 1818) 606ff and 616ff respectively.

[ii] Note delivered by Viscount Castlereagh to the Allied Ministers (11 September 1815), ibid 606.

[iii] Technically, the Laocoön Group is in Vatican City.

[iv] Dorothy Mackay Quynn, ‘The Art Confiscations of the Napoleonic Wars’ (1945) 50 (3) The American Historical Review 437, 442. See also Articles of Capitulation (30 August 1801), reproduced in Robert Wilson, History of the British Expedition to Egypt (2nd edn, Egerton 1803) 346-353, art 16.

[v] All statements made in this paragraph are examined at length in Catharine Titi, The Parthenon Marbles and International Law (Springer 2023).

[vi] Elgin to Long (1811, with a Postscript added February 1816) and Elgin to Bankes (13 March 1816), reproduced in Select Committee of the House of Commons, Report on the Earl of Elgin’s Collection of Sculptured Marbles (Bulmer 1816) reproduced as Appendices Nos 5 and 6, xv and xix. The Report is available at https://archive.org/details/gri_33125008272383/page/XVI/mode/2up?q=presents. It is worth running a search for ‘presents’ and ‘bribes’.

[vii] British Museum, ‘Maqdala collection’, undated, https://www.britishmuseum.org/about-us/british-museum-story/contested-objects-collection/maqdala-collection.

[viii] Ethonological Museum, ‘The Benin Collection in Berlin’, undated, https://www.smb.museum/en/museums-institutions/ethnologisches-museum/collection-research/benin-collection/.

[ix] Ibid.

[x] British Museum, ‘Benin Bronzes’, undated, https://www.britishmuseum.org/about-us/british-museum-story/contested-objects-collection/benin-bronzes.

[xi] Ibid.

[xii] British Museum, ‘Contested objects from the collection’, undated, https://www.britishmuseum.org/about-us/british-museum-story/contested-objects-collection.

[xiii] ‘Inside the British Museum: stolen treasures and a £1bn revamp’, The Times Magazine (10 May 2025) https://www.thetimes.com/culture/art/article/inside-the-british-museum-stolen-treasures-and-a-1bn-revamp-wp2zwcs53.

[xiv] Catharine Titi, The Parthenon Marbles and International Law (Springer 2023) 177; Catharine Titi, ‘Sorry, British Museum, a loan of the Parthenon Marbles is not a repatriation’, The Conversation (15 February 2023) https://theconversation.com/debate-sorry-british-museum-a-loan-of-the-parthenon-marbles-is-not-a-repatriation-199468.

[xv] ‘Returning Marbles to their birthplace, Times Letters’, BCRPM (13 May 2025) https://www.parthenonuk.com/latest-news/981-returning-marbles-to-their-birthplace-times-letters. The Times, where the letter was published, did not print these lines.

[xvi] Christopher Hitchens, The Parthenon Marbles (first published 1987, Verso 2008) 98.

[xvii] William St Clair, Lord Elgin and the Marbles (Oxford University Press 1998, reprinted 2003) 223.

[xviii] Christopher Hitchens, The Parthenon Marbles (first published 1987, Verso 2008) 98.

[xix] Arts Council England, ‘Reviewing Committee’ (2025) https://www.artscouncil.org.uk/supporting-arts-museums-and-libraries/supporting-collections-and-cultural-property/reviewing-committee-0.

[xx] At any one time only 1% of the British Museum’s collection is on public display, British Museum, ‘Fact Sheet’ (2019) https://www.britishmuseum.org/sites/default/files/2019-10/fact_sheet_bm_collection.pdf.

[xxi] British Museum, ‘The Parthenon Sculptures: The Trustees’ statement’ (accessed 27 May 2025) https://www.britishmuseum.org/about-us/british-museum-story/contested-objects-collection/parthenon-sculptures/parthenon#:~:text=The%20Trustees%20of%20the%20British%20Museum%20believe%20that%20there’s%20a,significance%20within%20world%20cultural%20history.

[xxii] Catharine Titi, The Parthenon Marbles and International Law (Springer 2023) 173-175; Catharine Titi, ‘« Diviser c’est détruire » : les marbres du Parthénon et l’intégrité des monuments’, The Conversation (21 March 2023) https://theconversation.com/diviser-cest-detruire-les-marbres-du-parthenon-et-lintegrite-des-monuments-201232.

[xxiii] Victor Ehikhamenor, ‘Give Us Back What Our Ancestors Made’, The New York Times (28 January 2020) https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/28/opinion/looted-benin-bronzes.html.

[xxiv] For some returns from UK insitutions, see Catharine Titi, The Parthenon Marbles and International Law (Springer 2023) 291-292.

[xxv] Raad voor Cultuur, ‘Summary of Report-Advisory Committee on the National Policy Framework for Colonial Collections’ (7 October 2020) https://www.raadvoorcultuur.nl/documenten/adviezen/2020/10/07/summary-of-report-advisory-committee-on-the-national-policy-framework-for-colonial-collections.

[xxvi] ‘Policy vision on collections from a colonial context’, 29 January 2021, https://committee.kolonialecollecties.nl/documents/2021/01/01/policy-vision-on-collections-from-a-colonial-context and Colonial Collections Committee, ‘Procedure’ https://committee.kolonialecollecties.nl/procedure.

[xxvii] For the reports of the Colonial Collections Committee, see ‘Publications’, https://committee.kolonialecollecties.nl/publications?size=n_10_n&filters%5B0%5D%5Bfield%5D=information_type&filters%5B0%5D%5Bvalues%5D%5B0%5D=Advice&filters%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=all.

[xxviii] Raad voor Cultuur, ‘Summary of Report-Advisory Committee on the National Policy Framework for Colonial Collections’ (7 October 2020) https://www.raadvoorcultuur.nl/documenten/adviezen/2020/10/07/summary-of-report-advisory-committee-on-the-national-policy-framework-for-colonial-collections.

[xxix] Hansard, Parliamentary Debates 1816 (vol 34, Hansard 1816) c 1031.

[xxx] Hansard, Abyssinian War House of Commons Debate: Motion for an Address (30 June 1871) (vol 207, Hansard 1871) cc 949-951.

 

 

 

Share This Post