The Sculptures were stolen. Elgin had no permission to remove them. The firman does not exist and never existed.

Five years have now passed since talks began, with great publicity, between the British Museum and Greece over the Parthenon Sculptures. Three years later, then-UK Prime Minister Sunak cancelled a meeting with Greece’s PM Mitsotakis because the latter referred to the reunification of the Parthenon Marbles in an interview with the BBC, prior to his meeting with Sunak. It was a huge, childish and clumsy insult on the part of Sunak, but Greece continued the talks with dignity, despite the incident.

It has been said that George Osborne, a former finance minister, wanted to make history and become the man with a solution to this long-standing, unresolved issue. He is the chairman of the board of directors of the British Museum and all of us that are campaigning for the return of these sculptures were excited at the prospect of something finally happening. Could this have been the moment of the triumphant return of Phidias’ masterpieces to Athens? Today they are in the evocative, but dark, Duveen Hall; would we see them again under the Attic light, where they should have always been?

The top floor, glass walled,  Parthenon Gallery of the Acropolis Museum, Athens, Greece

When I read this week that the talks had “collapsed”, I suspected that this was an exaggeration. The newspaper that published the news, the Telegraph, belongs to the right-wing press, which is against the return, and I suspect that many of its readers would be happy if the British Museum kept in possession of all the objects of questionable origin in its collection, without examining whether they really belonged to London, and in particular the sculptures from the Parthenon.

When the British ask me why I think these sculptures should be returned, I simply answer: “Because they were stolen. Elgin had no permission to remove them. The firman does not exist and never existed.”

Those who prefer these sculptures to remain in London are deliberately ignoring these facts. They are so well documented that repeating them becomes almost tedious.

I believe that the museum itself is behind the Museum Act of 1963. No law is engraved in stone. This one, for example, was modified in relation to works of art that had been stolen by the Nazis. It could also be modified in relation to works of art stolen by a British aristocrat, who wanted to please his wife by offering her some sculptures. It is simply a matter of will.

There has been no official statement that the talks have ended. More precisely, they seem to have stalled, because, after all this time, nothing has progressed. No agreement, no compromise, not even a “settlement” has been reached.

There is undoubtedly a sense of disappointment on the part of all those who hoped – perhaps naively – that the British Museum or the UK government, or both, would show generosity towards Greece. We are also extremely disappointed by Andy Burnham, who just three years ago stated that he believed that the Parthenon Marbles should be returned ‘without binding conditions’, that is, without any conditions whatsoever. Now that he is prime minister, he has abandoned this view. Shame.

The director of the British Museum, Nicholas Cullinan, is currently very satisfied, as the museum hosts an exhibition that attracts a large number of visitors, the result of an Anglo-French agreement to borrow the Bayeux Tapestry. There is something absurd in any comparison between this rather primitive work of embroidery and the Parthenon Marbles: there is no dispute over its ownership, it survives as a single work, it is a thousand years old (relatively young), it has no universal cultural significance and, and, and… The Parthenon Marbles and the Bayeux Tapestry have absolutely nothing in common. And once again the sculptures from the Parthenon are offended – and, in my opinion, Greece is also insulted that they are being compared.

Greece and all those campaigning in Britain for their return,  should continue to demand that the museum does the right thing. Patience is needed on our part, but sooner or later, whether with a change of regime there or just with a lightning strike on its roof, they will see the light. And this will illuminate the truth.

Article by Victoria Hislop first published in Kathimerini.

Share This Post